1. “Christmas Eve” – Punchy, Tenchy, Chirpy, Henchy, Santa, Mrs. Claus, Elves
2. Before Now Dasher – Underscore
3. “Now Dasher” – Santa, Elves, Reindeer, Henchy
4. “Somebody Like Me” – Punchy, Tenchy, Chirpy
5. “Somebody Like Me Henchy Tag” – Henchy
6. After Somebody Like Me – Underscore
7. “You’ll be a Santa Soon” – Santa, Nick, Elves, Henchy, Mrs. Claus, Tenchy, Punchy, Chirpy, Bee
8. Henchy’s Underscore 1 – Underscore
9. Evil Henchy Tag – Underscore
10. “Jingle Jam” – Santa, Elves, Henchy, Nick, Mrs. Claus, Bee, Reindeer
11. Before Naughty or Nice – Underscore
12. “Naughty or Nice” – Santa, Nick, Mrs. Claus, Chirpy, Punchy, Tenchy
13. Henchy Underscore 2: Letter Shredding – Underscore
14. Evil Henchy Tag 2 – Underscore
15. Where Have All the Letters Gone? – Underscore
16. “Santa Dot Com” – Nick, Santa, Bee, Elves, Mrs. Claus, Henchy
17. Henchy Underscore 3: Stealing the List – Underscore
18. Evil Henchy Tag 3 – Underscore
19. Reindeer Round-up Transition – Underscore
20. “The Good, the Bad, and Everything Between” – Mrs. Claus, Santa
21. Henchy Underscore 4 – Underscore
22. The Search for the Naughty or Nice List – Underscore
23. Naughty or Nice? (Audience Participation) – Underscore
24. “The Good, the Bad, and Everything Between (Reprise)” – Bee, Nick, Santa, Mrs. Claus
25. “Christmas Eve Transition and Reprise” – Punchy, Tenchy, Chirpy, Bee, Nick
26. “What Would Santa Do?” – Bee, Henchy, Nick, Elves, Reindeer
27. What Would Santa Do — Emergency Sleigh Landing – Underscore
28. Punchy in Love – Underscore
29. “A Very Merry Christmas to Us All” – Santa, Henchy, Mrs. Claus, Nick, Bee, All
30. Bows – Underscore